OPINION: In grudging support of the 1% (tax rate)

Posted

On Nov. 3, Florida voters passed "Amendment 3," under which homeowners will pay property tax on less of their homes' values through a "homestead exemption" increase.

Since 2008, that exemption has mean that homeowners don't pay certain property taxes ("school taxes" are unaffected) on the first $50,000 in assessed value of their main residences (second homes receive no exemption). In 2027, that exemption will increase to $150,000; in 2028, to $250,000.

Naturally, opponents of Amendment 3 warned that "services will be cut." Public libraries will shut down. The already horrendously potholed county roads will get worse. Florida will become a Dickensian sewer of poverty.

And, naturally, those opponents who happen to sit on city councils and county commissions are already hard at work looking for ways to replace "lost revenues" with "fees" and non-property taxes.

In reality, Florida's government revenues and spending have constantly increased since 2008 — and fast. Faster than wages. Faster than inflation. The increased homestead exemption will slightly reduce the rate of that increase rather than actually cutting revenues and spending.

That's the typical government attitude. All your money REALLY belongs to them, any of it they generously let you keep for yourself is a gift, and the amount they take is a constant: More.

Governor Ron DeSantis has called for a special legislative session to pass a "Taxpayer Bill of Rights" that might take the edge off these county and local money grabs. But what Florida and other states, not to mention the federal government, really need is a hard limit on taxes.

While I'd personally like to see that limit set at "not one thin dime," I'm in a moderate mood, and 1% seems like a reasonable compromise. It's also an historically justifiable one.

After an eight-year war of secession, the United States achieved its independence from the United Kingdom in 1783. One of the rallying cries for that war as "no taxation without representation!" Since the colonists weren't represented in the British parliament, they quite reasonably suggested that said parliament had no authority to tax them.

I guess representation, and maybe even democracy, are worthy goals if we're going to tolerate political government at all, but it's worth asking: Just how heavily were the colonists burdened by unrepresented taxation?

The answer, as best I can tell from AI queries, search engine noodling, and recollections of past readings, is: 1-1.5% of income, on average.

Today, Americans pay an average of 27% of their incomes in federal, state, and county/local taxes.

Quite the disparity. Apparently "representation" wasn't the solution to burdensome tax demands after all.

My own solution — once again grudgingly conceding that most people still superstitiously believe they "need" political government at all — is to constitutionally limit each level of government to 1% of their subjects' incomes.

That is:

The federal government gets 1%.

Each state government gets 1%.

Each county and/or local government (combined) gets 1%.

Which means that Americans would still end up paying two or three times as much in taxes as they did under British rule, but like I said, I'm in a moderate mood.

As a further example of my moderation, I'll throw in a nod to "democracy." Let voters raise that county/local maximum periodically if they so choose, so long as the increase isn't retroactive and so long as those who object are compensated for moving expenses should they choose to leave their tax-happy locales.

As to collecting the 1%, there are arguments for/against various tax schemes (income, sales, property, etc.), but let's leave that up to voters (or their "representatives") as well.

Using GDP as a proxy for income, my proposal would give the federal government a 2027 budget of about $330 billion — $40 billion more than it spent in the year 2000. To the best of my recollection, we all got by, at least as well then as now, at those taxing/spending levels. State and local takes would obviously vary, but my point here is that even if many of us WANT government, it CAN get too big, and HAS been too big for a long time.

Creeping confiscatory taxation as done in America — and in Florida — is the road toward Mussolini's fascism: "Everything within the state, nothing outside the state,  nothing against the state." If we won't eliminate it, we should at least put it on a leash.

Thomas L. Knapp (X: @thomaslknapp | Bluesky: @knappster.bsky.social | Mastodon: @knappster) is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism (thegarrisoncenter.org). He lives and works in north central Florida.

taxes Florida property taxes government spending
Advertisement